Evaluation of leaf removal as a means to reduce nutrient concentrations and loads in urban stormwater

rebecca.killalea@canberra.edu.au on 14 Mar 2022
Back to citations

All evidence records currently entered in EcoEvidEx for this citation are shown below.
An evidence record consists of an association between two variables, plus information about the nature of that relationship, the study design by which it was observed, and environmental context.
Click on an evidence record below to view or edit the complete evidence record.
Click 'Add evidence' to add a new evidence record for this citation, or copy an existing evidence record by selecting that record then using the 'Duplicate evidence' option.

Author(s)
Selbig, W. R.
Year
2016
Title
Evaluation of leaf removal as a means to reduce nutrient concentrations and loads in urban stormwater
Source
Science of The Total Environment
DOI
10.1016/j.scitotenv.2016.07.003
Volume
571
Pages
124-133
ISSN/ISBN
0048-9697
Abstract

While the sources of nutrients to urban stormwater are many, the primary contributor is often organic detritus, especially in areas with dense overhead tree canopy. One way to remove organic detritus before it becomes entrained in runoff is to implement a city-wide leaf collection and street cleaning program. Improving our knowledge of the potential reduction of nutrients to stormwater through removal of leaves and other organic detritus on streets could help tailor more targeted municipal leaf collection programs. This study characterized an upper ideal limit in reductions of total and dissolved forms of phosphorus and nitrogen in stormwater through implementation of a municipal leaf collection and street cleaning program in Madison, WI, USA. Additional measures were taken to remove leaf litter from street surfaces prior to precipitation events. Loads of total and dissolved phosphorus were reduced by 84 and 83% (p < 0.05), and total and dissolved nitrogen by 74 and 71% (p < 0.05) with an active leaf removal program. Without leaf removal, 56% of the annual total phosphorus yield (winter excluded) was due to leaf litter in the fall compared to 16% with leaf removal. Despite significant reductions in load, total nitrogen showed only minor changes in fall yields without and with leaf removal at 19 and 16%, respectively. The majority of nutrient concentrations were in the dissolved fraction making source control through leaf removal one of the few treatment options available to environmental managers when reducing the amount of dissolved nutrients in stormwater runoff. Subsequently, the efficiency, frequency, and timing of leaf removal and street cleaning are the primary factors to consider when developing a leaf management program.

Evidence

Cause Effect Response measure type Habitat Country Modified
Plants (riparian) - other (Decrease)
Decreased leaf litter on ground due to manual leaf removal.
Water quality - nutrients (nitrogen) (Decrease)
Dissolved nitrogen and total nitrogen were significantly reduced in the fall by 71% and 74% respectively in the presence of an active leaf removal program. The program also resulted in significant removal during Spring for both TN (52%) and DN (44%).
Other Other United States 14-Mar-2022
Plants (riparian) - other (Decrease)
Decreased leaf litter on ground due to manual leaf removal.
Water quality - nutrients (phosphorus) (Decrease)
Dissolved phosphorus and total phosphorus were significantly reduced in the fall by 83% and 84% respectively in the presence of an active leaf removal program. The program also resulted in significant removal during Spring for both TP (45%) and DP (51%) and removal during Summer of TP (36%) (but not DP).
Other Other United States 14-Mar-2022