Components of floating emergent macrophyte treatment wetlands influencing removal of stormwater pollutants

rebecca.killalea@canberra.edu.au on 31 Jan 2022
Back to citations

All evidence records currently entered in EcoEvidEx for this citation are shown below.
An evidence record consists of an association between two variables, plus information about the nature of that relationship, the study design by which it was observed, and environmental context.
Click on an evidence record below to view or edit the complete evidence record.
Click 'Add evidence' to add a new evidence record for this citation, or copy an existing evidence record by selecting that record then using the 'Duplicate evidence' option.

Author(s)
Tanner, C. C., & Headley, T. R.
Year
2011
Title
Components of floating emergent macrophyte treatment wetlands influencing removal of stormwater pollutants
Source
Ecological Engineering
DOI
10.1016/j.ecoleng.2010.12.012
Volume
37
Issue
3
Pages
474-486
ISSN/ISBN
0925-8574
Abstract

Floating treatment wetlands planted with emergent macrophytes (FTWs) provide an innovative option for treating urban stormwaters. Emergent plants grow on a mat floating on the water surface, rather than rooted in the bottom sediments. They are therefore able to tolerate the wide fluctuations in water depths that are typical of stormwater ponds. To better understand the treatment capabilities of FTWs, a series of replicated (n = 3) mesocosm experiments (12×0.7m3 tanks using 0.36m2 floating mats) were conducted over seven day periods to examine the influence of constituent components of FTWs (floating mat, soil media, and four different emergent macrophyte species) for removal of copper, zinc, phosphorus and fine suspended solids (FSS) from synthetic stormwater. The presence of a planted floating mat significantly (P < 0.05) improved removal of copper (>6-fold), fine suspended particles (∼3-fold reduction in turbidity) and dissolved reactive P (in the presence of FSS) compared to the control. Living plants provided a large submerged root surface-area (4.6–9.3m2 of primary roots m−2 mat) for biofilm development and played a key role in the removal of Cu, P and FSS. Uptake of Cu and P into plant tissues during the trials could only account for a small fraction of the additional removal found in the planted FTWs, and non-planted floating mats with artificial roots providing similar surface area generally did not provide equivalent benefits. These responses suggest that release of bioactive compounds from the plant roots, or changes in physico-chemical conditions in the water column and/or soils in the planted FTWs indirectly enhanced removal processes by modifying metal speciation (e.g. stimulating complexation or flocculation of dissolved fractions) and/or the sorption characteristics of biofilms. The removal of dissolved zinc was enhanced by the inclusion of a floating mat containing organic soil media, with reduced removal when vegetated with all except one of the test species. The results indicate that planted FTWs are capable of achieving dissolved Cu and Zn mass removal rates in the order of 5.6–7.7mgm−2 d−1 and 25–104mgm−2 d−1, respectively, which compare favourably to removal rates reported for conventional surface flow constructed wetlands treating urban stormwaters. Although not directly measured in the present study, the removal of particulate-bound metals is also likely to be high given that the FTWs removed approximately 34–42% of the turbidity associated with very fine suspended particulates within three days. This study illustrates the promise of FTWs for stormwater treatment, and supports the need for larger-scale, longer-term studies to evaluate their sustainable treatment performance.

Evidence

Cause Effect Response measure type Habitat Country Modified
Plants (aquatic)
Floating treatment wetlands
Water quality - metals (Decrease)
Reduction of zinc from water. Zinc removal varied across treatments but all were lower than the control which was negligible. Less than 40% Zn reduction was achieved by any treatment.
Mean difference Artificial New Zealand 15-Feb-2022
Plants (aquatic)
Floating treatment wetlands
Water quality - metals (Decrease)
Reduction of copper from water. The presence of planted floating mats significantly improved removal of copper from the synthetic stormwater. Planted treatments resulted in 65-75% reduction in total Cu concentrations after 7 days. The synthetic root treatment acheived Cu reduction of 50% after 7 days whilst the floating mat with soil media and floating mat treatments achieved 43% and 30% reduction respectively. Little change was seen in the control.
Mean difference Artificial New Zealand 15-Feb-2022
Plants (aquatic)
Floating treatment wetlands
Water quality - nutrients (phosphorus) (Decrease)
Reduction of dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP) from water. The presence of planted floating mats (in the presence of fine suspended solids) significantly improved removal of phosphorus from the synthetic stormwater. Removal rates ranged from 30% to 60% of DRP and 58% TP after 7 days for planted treatments.
Mean difference Artificial New Zealand 15-Feb-2022